Just a question, from what I gather, the worst our sun can do to us is take down satellites (which would be devastating yes). I have read the solar flare page and just to confirm, our sun is not capable of anything along the lines of what happened in Knowing, correct?
Be that as it may, just wondering if there's any science behind you're comment that you can forward me to. So far from what I have got from Dr. Ian O'Neil is that it is absolutely an impossibility. The only flare seen that was capable of something like this came from a huge red giant with a binary partner.
Well, you realize that it is impossible to provide science that doesn't exist, right? The best we can do is say that these kinds of massive outbursts do occur but not in our kind of star. You'd have to have something disturbing it, or have an extremely massive star (like eta Carina) to create a "knowing" type of event.
As far as the science: Grab a scope. Look outside at the stars. See how they are almost all these nice point sources? There are a few planetary nebula and supernova remnants around, but compared to "normal" stars they are very rare.
If these events were common, we would see many more emission nebula like we see around eta Carina (which I can't see from here, but hope to see in person some day). These emission nebula are hot clouds of gas lit up by stars embedded in them. They are common in 'starburst' areas like the Orion nebula, where stars are forming, but as the stars light up, they blow the emission nebula away and apart.
So, the available evidence is that sun-like "Type G" stars (and if I recall correctly, that is about 8% of the local stars you see at night) do not have these massive outbursts. Stars that have 'outbursts' are variable stars, and they are not the nice, stable, middle-aged stars like our sun.
As far as Ian O'Neill's comment, I'd trust what he says in this area completely. He is a solar physicist. I'm just an amateur astronomer.
"Do you ever think about things you do think about?" - Henry Drummond to Matthew Harrison Brady in Inherit the Wind
hey, i just wanted to say that there were 2 x class flares in october 2003 in one day. the strongest possible flares that the sun can deliver at us, and nothing happened. just a few power outtages in a few places, for a few hours, thats it.
Life has existed here on Earth at least 500 million years, and it is reasonable to think in that amount of time the Sun must have put out some pretty nasty flares. Yet we're here. Case closed.