Hi guys. I have a question regarding part of an idea put forward by a certain Belgian grapefruit. According to him, all volcanos on earth erupt at the same time during a pole reversal that happens every 11,500 years. Before I go any further, I'd like to state that I'm well aware this man is wrong and has been shown to be wrong on many points by a lot of others here, but I feel like there are people still very concerned by his claims, so just trying to add another reason he's wrong. My question is this: the liquid core of the earth, as far as I'm aware, was created due to the energy of impacts on earth over millions of years. This molten core is what makes our planet volcanically active. Now, if indeed all volcanos on earth erupted at the same time every 11,500 years, and had been doing so for billions of years, would there even be a molten liquid core left? Wouldn't this planet be covered in dormant volcanos like mars? Wouldn't the loss of all that heat make this planet uninhabitable? Again, this is simply a question, if someone who knows better than I do could tell me if I'm making an accurate assumption here, I'd really appreciate it.
I also liked to point out in regard to this claim before that we have hard evidence that the last time Yellowstone erupted was around 640,000 years ago. Now we have records of other volcano's as well like Toba that erupted around 75,000 years ago. People use these numbers as say we are "overdue" for an eruption. I look at these numbers and think about what you said above in a way, because the evidence of the last eruptions of even just those two I listed above refute the claims that you posted above.
“In all matters of opinion, our adversaries are insane.” - Oscar Wilde
I agree with you diesel, I'm just trying to point out another error in mr "I'm 100% sure's" work. When you think of the glaringly obvious mistakes he's made it makes you wonder how in gods name he can say that with a straight face.
James was e-mailed a reply to his questions by the person who made the documentary about PG. He said that he was most likely mentally unstable from what he could tell. His claims are of a religious nature, and that is why he ignores the scientific evidence against him, because he knows it proves him wrong.
“In all matters of opinion, our adversaries are insane.” - Oscar Wilde
Can I ask you a question diesel, are you convinced he's wrong now?
I have greatly improved over the past couple of months. I am back to pretty much normal now. I have done a lot of research and broke down a lot of claims to get back to where I am now. I have also read a lot of things posted on this website and have posted a lot of things as well. Thinking logically can make a world of difference. I have my moments that I get a bit anxious, but for the most part I can think logically and see that all the evidence points to him being wrong. He has been wrong already on numerous things that I have posted here about.
“In all matters of opinion, our adversaries are insane.” - Oscar Wilde
That's great. Really glad that people seem to be realising geryl is wrong. Well done to you, I'm really happy to see your doing better. The reason I posted this was to help you and James a bit more, if your both ok now it seems a bit pointless.
It is never pointless to bring up more reasons that he is wrong, and I like what you brought up because it isn't a perspective I had looked at yet. It still helped me, and I'm sure it will help others as well.
“In all matters of opinion, our adversaries are insane.” - Oscar Wilde






